<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<TEI xmlns="http://www.tei-c.org/ns/1.0" xmlns:np="http://www.newtonproject.sussex.ac.uk/ns/nonTEI" xml:id="THEM00175" type="transcription" subtype="child">
<teiHeader>
<fileDesc>
<titleStmt>
<title>Notes on Newton's dispute with Robert Hooke</title>
<author xml:id="jc"><persName key="nameid_24" sort="Conduitt, John" ref="nameid_24" xml:base="http://www.newtonproject.sussex.ac.uk/catalogue/xml/persNames.xml">John Conduitt</persName></author>

</titleStmt>
<extent><hi rend="italic">c.</hi> <num n="word_count" value="377">377</num> words</extent>

<publicationStmt>
<authority>Newton Project</authority>
<pubPlace>London</pubPlace>
<date>2006</date>
<publisher>Newton Project, Imperial College</publisher>
<availability n="lic-text" status="restricted"><licence target="http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/"><p>This text is licensed under a <ref target="http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/">Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License</ref>.</p></licence></availability>
</publicationStmt>
<notesStmt>
<note type="metadataLine"><hi rend="italic">c.</hi> 1727-8, <hi rend="italic">c.</hi> 382 words, 4 pp.</note>
<note n="pages">4 pp.</note>
<note n="related_texts">
<linkGrp n="document_relations" xml:base="http://www.newtonproject.sussex.ac.uk/view/normalized/"><ptr type="next_part" target="THEM00176">Notes on Newton's suitability for canonisation if not deification [Keynes Ms. 130.14]</ptr><ptr type="parent" target="THEM00029">Keynes Ms. 130</ptr><ptr type="previous_part" target="THEM00174">Extracts from Newton's notebooks [Keynes Ms. 130.12]</ptr></linkGrp>
</note>
</notesStmt>
<sourceDesc><bibl type="simple" n="custodian_5" sortKey="keynes_ms._130.13" subtype="Manuscript">Keynes Ms. 130.13, King's College, Cambridge, UK</bibl>
<msDesc>
<msIdentifier>
<country>UK</country><settlement>Cambridge</settlement><repository n="custodian_5">King's College</repository>
<collection>Keynes Mss</collection>
<idno n="Keynes Ms. 130.13">Keynes Ms. 130.13</idno>
</msIdentifier>
<history>
<provenance n="sothebylot">SL212</provenance>
</history>
<additional>
<surrogates>
<p n="ChHReel"><num>17</num></p>
</surrogates>
</additional>
</msDesc>

</sourceDesc>
</fileDesc>
<profileDesc>
<creation>
<origDate when="1727-03-19"><hi rend="italic">c.</hi> 1727-8</origDate>
</creation>
<langUsage>
<language ident="eng">English</language>
</langUsage>
<handNotes>
<handNote sameAs="#jc">Holograph</handNote>
</handNotes>
</profileDesc>
<encodingDesc>
<classDecl><taxonomy><category><catDesc n="Biography">Biography</catDesc></category></taxonomy></classDecl>
</encodingDesc>
<revisionDesc>
<change when="2001-01-01" type="metadata">Catalogue information compiled by Rob Iliffe, Peter Spargo &amp; John Young</change>
<change when="2004-06-01">Tagged transcription by <name xml:id="rhiggitt">Rebekah Higgitt</name></change>
<change when="2004-08-01" status="released">Checked against microfilm by <name xml:id="jy">John Young</name></change>
<change when="2006-10-25">Coding audited and updated to Newton v2.0 DTD by <name xml:id="mjh">Michael Hawkins</name></change>
<change when="2008-12-09">Metadata revised by <name>John Young</name></change>
<change when="2009-04-20">Updated to Newton V3.0 (TEI P5 Schema) by <name>Michael Hawkins</name></change>
<change when="2011-09-29" type="metadata">Catalogue exported to teiHeader by <name>Michael Hawkins</name></change>
</revisionDesc>
</teiHeader>
<text>
<body>
<div>
<pb xml:id="p001" n="1"/>
<p rend="indent15" xml:id="par1">p. 49 – in Iones –</p>
<p rend="indent0" xml:id="par2">In 1673 D<hi rend="superscript">r</hi> Hook wrote to him <lb xml:id="l1"/>to send him something new <lb xml:id="l2"/>for the transactions whereupon <lb xml:id="l3"/>he sent him a little dissertation <lb xml:id="l4"/> to confute that co<choice><orig>m̄</orig><reg>mm</reg></choice>on objection <lb xml:id="l5"/><del type="strikethrough"><choice><abbr>w<hi rend="superscript">ch</hi></abbr><expan>which</expan></choice> is</del> that if it were true <lb xml:id="l6"/>that the earth moved from West to East all falling <lb xml:id="l7"/>bodies would be left to the <lb xml:id="l8"/>West, &amp; maintained that <lb xml:id="l9"/>on the contrary they would <lb xml:id="l10"/>fall a little Eastward &amp; <lb xml:id="l11"/>having described a curve <lb xml:id="l12"/>with his hand to represent <pb xml:id="p002" n="2"/> the motion of a falling body <lb xml:id="l13"/>he drew a negligent stroke <lb xml:id="l14"/>with his pen from whence <lb xml:id="l15"/>D<hi rend="superscript">r</hi> Hook took occasion to <lb xml:id="l16"/>imagine <del type="strikethrough">it</del> <add place="supralinear" indicator="yes">that he meant the curve</add> would be a <lb xml:id="l17"/>spiral, whereupon the <choice><abbr>D<hi rend="superscript">r</hi></abbr><expan>Doctor</expan></choice> <lb xml:id="l18"/>wrote to him that the curve <lb xml:id="l19"/>would be an Ellipsis &amp; that <lb xml:id="l20"/>the body would move <lb xml:id="l21"/>according to Kepler's notion <lb xml:id="l22"/><choice><abbr>w<hi rend="superscript">ch</hi></abbr><expan>which</expan></choice> gave <choice><abbr>S<hi rend="superscript">r</hi></abbr><expan>Sir</expan></choice> I. N. an occasion <lb xml:id="l23"/>to examine the thing <lb xml:id="l24"/>thoroughly &amp; for the foundation <lb xml:id="l25"/>of the calculus <add place="supralinear" indicator="yes">he</add> intended he <pb xml:id="p003" n="3"/> laid down this proposition <lb xml:id="l26"/>that the areas described <lb xml:id="l27"/>in equal times were equal <lb xml:id="l28"/><choice><abbr>w<hi rend="superscript">ch</hi></abbr><expan>which</expan></choice> <choice><abbr>tho<hi rend="superscript">u</hi></abbr><expan>though</expan></choice> assumed by Kepler <lb xml:id="l29"/>was not by him demonstrated <lb xml:id="l30"/>of <choice><abbr>w<hi rend="superscript">ch</hi></abbr><expan>which</expan></choice> demonstration the <lb xml:id="l31"/>first glory is due to <choice><abbr>S<hi rend="superscript">r</hi></abbr><expan>Sir</expan></choice> I.</p>
<p rend="indent0" xml:id="par3"><choice><abbr>Mem<hi rend="superscript">m</hi></abbr><expan>Memorandum</expan></choice> Pemberton in his <lb xml:id="l32"/>preface <choice><abbr>w<hi rend="superscript">ch</hi></abbr><expan>which</expan></choice> vide mentions <lb xml:id="l33"/>this in <del type="strikethrough">a different</del> <add place="supralinear" indicator="no">another</add> manner – <lb xml:id="l34"/>He says particularly – Upon this <lb xml:id="l35"/>principle he found the line <lb xml:id="l36"/>described by a falling body <lb xml:id="l37"/>to be an Elipsis the center of <lb xml:id="l38"/>the earth being one focus <pb xml:id="p004" n="4"/> &amp; the primary planets <lb xml:id="l39"/>moving in such orbits round <lb xml:id="l40"/>the sun he had the satisfaction <lb xml:id="l41"/>to see that this enquiry <choice><abbr>w<hi rend="superscript">ch</hi></abbr><expan>which</expan></choice> he had undertaken merely out <lb xml:id="l42"/>of curiosity could be applied <lb xml:id="l43"/>to the greatest purposes – <lb xml:id="l44"/>Hereupon he composed near <lb xml:id="l45"/>a dozen propositions relating <lb xml:id="l46"/>to the <add place="supralinear" indicator="yes">motion of the</add> primary <del type="strikethrough">motions</del> planets <lb xml:id="l47"/>about the sun, &amp; from <add place="supralinear" indicator="yes">no other materials but</add> those <lb xml:id="l48"/>few propositions only he <lb xml:id="l49"/>composed his principia <lb xml:id="l50"/>in the space of one year <lb xml:id="l51"/>&amp; half —– <choice><abbr>S<hi rend="superscript">r</hi></abbr><expan>Sir</expan></choice> <choice><abbr>I<hi rend="superscript">s</hi></abbr><expan>Isaac</expan></choice> <choice><abbr>N.</abbr><expan>Newton</expan></choice> says in one of <lb xml:id="l52"/>his papers relating to Leibnitz that he wrote <lb xml:id="l53"/>the Principia in 17 or 18 months beginning the <lb xml:id="l54"/>end of <choice><abbr>Dec<hi rend="superscript">r</hi></abbr><expan>December</expan></choice> <choice type="oldCorr"><sic>1784</sic><corr>1684</corr></choice> – &amp; sending it to the Society in May – <lb xml:id="l55"/>1686 except about 10 or 12 of the propositions <lb xml:id="l56"/><choice><abbr>w<hi rend="superscript">ch</hi></abbr><expan>which</expan></choice> were composed before Viz. two in 1679 – &amp; <lb xml:id="l57"/>the rest in Iune &amp; Iuly – 1684 —</p>
</div>
</body>
</text>
</TEI>